October 4, 2023

Mirabilia Reviews & Ratings

Share Your Opinion – Write Your Own Review!

Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream

Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Cakes

A review of Cold Stone Creamery gourmet ice cream cake, it includes traditional hard-packed ice cream to soft serve varieties, read the review.

  • Editor Rating

  • Rated 4.5 stars
  • Outstanding

  • Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Cake Review
  • Reviewed by:
  • Published on:
  • Last modified: July 21, 2015
  • Quality
    Editor: 95%
  • Price
    Editor: 90%
  • Overall
    Editor: 95%

Review Summary:

Cold Stone Creamery is a gourmet ice cream company where ice cream is made on location and is always sweet, flavorful, and delicious. My son wanted something different for his birthday cake. Usually, my go to cake is a cheesecake from The Cheesecake Factory. This time, however, I elected to get an ice cream cake from The Stone Cold Creamery. The ice cream cake was a huge hit with everyone -- not a single bit left! The level of service at the CSC location I visited was impeccable and this helped to make it a nice experience.

Knowing I wanted a Reece's cup flavor to the cake, the employee suggested peanut butter ice cream mixed with Reece's cup, with a layer of peanut butter in the middle. The customer creates their own special cake with the many different add-ins. Oreo cookies, white chocolate, Butterfinger, Brownies, and Heath Bar are just a small sample of over 50 different mix-ins. Paired with the 23 different flavors of ice cream, your Stone Cold Creamery cake can be a unique combination of desired flavors.

The employee at Cold Stone Creamery was friendly and prepared to show me the variety of cakes. There were pictures and information on how many people each cake feeds. The process of ordering was simple. They will write messages on the cakes too, just like a bakery, which is a huge plus when buying a birthday cake. I chose my order and set up a pick up time for the next day.

The cake was created perfectly. Every one enjoyed the taste and finished their slice. The peanut butter layer added a really decadent flavor. The color of the frosting for the Happy Birthday salutation should have been a brighter red. I will know for next time. Other than that, it was a great experience. Everyone at the party enjoyed loved it, better perhaps than our usual banana cheesecake from The Cheesecake Factory.

Cold Stone Creamery ice cream cakes are made with the finest ingredients. The taste between this and a soft serve ice cream cake is not even in the same rank. I haven't purchased a soft serve cake ever since trying the offerings of Cold Stone Creamery. The overall taste and appearance of my son's cake was excellent, and they even have football shaped cakes! If you are interested in securing the best ice cream cake around, make sure to stop into a Cold Stone Creamery parlor. You will be so glad you did.